Tag: Holocaust

  • Short Story Review: “Trude” by Joshua Cohen

    (The short story “Trude” by Joshua Cohen appeared in the November 23rd, 2026 issue of The New Yorker.)

    Photograph by Adam Śmigielski / Getty

    I am not a fan of excerpts from novels that are passed off as short stories. Novels are novels, and short stories; each has its own rules, form, goals, intention and all the other stuff that English professors tried to drill in all of our heads. Also, I do have a chip on my shoulder when it comes to short stories, as I believe as a form of storytelling, short fiction doesn’t get enough respect. Then I read “Trude” which reminded me that I can be a pretentious little man, and I should really shut the hell up, and let storytellers tell their stories.

    The mastery that Joshua Cohen displays as he orchestrates this tragedy cannot be overstated. Cynically, I knew where this story was going, but half way through it, I began to feel that I owed these characters, I had to follow them, I needed to know their fate. This story is constructed and paced in a manner which gives it a breath to expand, and draws us in to this world. Wit and a little humor are sprinkled in the beginning, but as the story develops, these breaks in tension evaporate, only to be replaced by a tension and dread of what is out there before them. I was also drawn in to this piece by the use of prose; how sparse and direct it was, but not in a Hemmingway-style of boiling down to the most basic. This was a simplicity that creates spaces for the reader to fill in the emotion without being told how to feel. It has been awhile since I felt so respected by a writer; that I was trusted by the writer to take part in this story, that I was going to feel it, and it would be okay.

    I was gutted by this story, though I still felt the hope that the parents had for their son in England, which kept me alive in this story, and Cohen played that masterfully in “Trude.” I am always impressed by story tellers who can take serious material, and not just make a compelling story out of it, but can make their audience hopeful that action can be taken to make the world a better place. I wanted to cry for the characters in “Trude,” but more importantly, the story made me want to make this world a better place for them.